A referencedependent model, the quarterly journal of economics, oxford university press, vol. For example, kahneman, knetsch, and thaler 1990, p. The book systematically analyzes the relationships between loss aversion and the law. Thaler the journal of economic perspectives, 51, pp. The loss aversion ratio has been estimated in several experiments and is usually in the. Loss aversion is a central element of prospect theory, the dominant theory of. We suspect that this is the typical interpretation of traditional loss aversion for most. The empirical section of the paper estimates the level of loss aversion implied by historical u. As a result, due to loss aversion, investors demand a higher average return from stocks than bills. Humans have a bias against loss and this has been proved in many behavioral studies.
The mit press is a leading publisher of books and journals at the intersection of science, technology, and the arts. Loss aversion the chocolate you lost can never be re. T ax compliance and prospect theory some theoretical studies in the area of prospect theory that focus on. People are more willing to take risks or behave dishonestly. The psychological and neural basis of loss aversion rutledge lab. For those of you who are regular readers of this blog, youll know that one of our most popular and most visited topics is that of consumer psychology and how we can utilise this in marketing for good, not for evil. Loss aversion, the fact that losses have a greater impact than gains, is a. This is particularly surprising if one considers the strong emphasis on individual differences in both economics and psychology. Loss aversion is the idea that we feel more pain at losing something than we feel pleased or excited when we gain something of an equal value. First, because behavioral economics largely emerged in reaction to neoclassical economics, a historical excursion allows us to paint a fuller picture of the views against which behavioral economics reacted. A critical behavioural economics and behavioural science. Loss aversion is not understood as the idea that losses can or sometimes loom larger than gains, but that losses inherently, perhaps inescapably, outweigh gains. Of all of the insights from behavioral economics that have found their way into mainstream financial planning knowledge, perhaps none is more wellknown than loss aversionthe idea that losses loom larger than gains i.
His ork inspired man follo ers and helped make kahneman and tversk s article i1979j one of the 8most cited in all of economics isee barberis 20 for an overvie j. The rejection of attractive gambles, loss aversion, and the lemon avoidance heuristic. The paper concludes with a discussion of the empirical findings, a future research agenda, and possible policy implications. Loss aversion bias can make investors dwell excessively on risk avoidance when evaluating possible gains, since dodging a loss is a more urgent concern than seeking a profit. Jan 21, 2016 loss aversion is a powerful psychological motivator. Revise the belief in loss aversion psychology frontiers. Behavioral economics to appear in elseviers handbook.
Humans may be hardwired to be loss averse due to asymmetric evolutionary pressure on losses and gains. Thus, people make decisions based on the potential gain or losses relative to their specific situation the reference point rather than in absolute. It assumes that consumers reference point is determined by their expectations. Rather, behavioral economics should be considered simply a return to the kind of openminded, intuitively motivated discipline that was.
Kahneman won the nobel prize in 2002 for this study integrating psychology into. First, lets begin by outlining what loss aversion is. Asset pricing, industrial organization data from downtown boston in the 1990s show that loss aversion determines seller behavior in the housing market. Evidence from the housing market david genesove, christopher mayer. If you want to unleash the geek in you, look for the study online entitled prospect theory. In cognitive psychology and decision theory, loss aversion refers to peoples tendency to prefer avoiding losses to acquiring equivalent gains. Previous literature loss aversion the theory of loss aversion, as might be applied to the real estate market. Condominium owners subject to nominal losses 1 set higher asking prices of 2535 percent of the difference between the propertys expected selling price and their original purchase price. The endowment effect, loss aversion, and status quo bias by daniel kahneman, jack l. Amos tversky 19371996 was a towering figure in the cognitive and decision sciences. Behavioral economics to appear in elseviers handbook of the philosophy of science, vol.
Freund and ozden provide new survey evidence showing that loss aversion and reference dependence are important in shaping peoples perception of trade policy. Nevertheless, the aversion toward incurring losses is a strong and reliable effect, and the value of avoiding a loss is usually twice as high as the value of acquiring an equivalent gain. Loss aversion is related to such phenomena as the status quo and omission biases, the endowment effect, and escalation of commitment. Habit recode uses loss aversion to keep you accountable and help you stick to your goals. Loss aversion refers to our tendency to strongly prefer avoiding losses over acquiring gains. Pdf exploring the nature of loss aversion researchgate.
Second, because most of the critics of behavioral economics have a neoclassical background, it allows us to achieve a better. Loss aversion theory the economics of design interaction. The principle of loss aversion is fundamental in the development of behavioral economics. Some version of this figure has appeared in every economics textbook written in the. The idea suggests that people have a tendency to stick with what they have unless there is a good reason to switch. Contradictory studies of loss aversion ert, e erev, i. Many of the models of financial economics relied on assumptions about human decisionmaking. Kahneman and tverskys prospect theory is probably the most influential contribution to behavioral economics, and loss aversion is the most important element. Pdf we examine an unexplored connection between loss aversion and international consumption smoothing. If only i had been more careful and not lost the money. Loss aversion the psychological propensity that losses loom larger than equalsized gains relative to a reference point can occur in riskless and in risky choices, as argued in two seminal papers by amos tversky and daniel kahneman kahneman and tversky 1979. Loss aversion can be explained by the way people view the value of consequences. Behavioural welfare economics does not model human psychology as it really is, but rather as faulty econs.
Emotion regulation reduces loss aversion and decreases. Linking loss aversion and present bias with overspending. Thus, people make decisions based on the potential gain or losses relative to their specific situation the reference point rather than in absolute terms. It represents the multiplicative weighting of the subjective value of losses relative to gains. Relative to loss aversion, however, the effect of risk aversion on overspending is less significant.
It is a human tendency to avoid a loss as much as possible. Oct 10, 2015 loss aversion is a powerful psychological phenomenon which small business owners in fact, businesses of all sizes should be aware of, and can utilise. We test a hypothesis that the coefficient for loss aversion is equal to that for risk aversion. Data from downtown boston in the 1990s show that loss aversion determines seller behavior in the housing market. Loss aversion is a powerful psychological phenomenon which small business owners in fact, businesses of all sizes should be aware. His work was ingenious, exciting, and influential, spanning topics from intuition to statistics to behavioral economics. Infante and friends provide a rejoinder working paper pdf. An example for loss aversion in riskless choice is the. Pope says that the study explores loss aversion a bias in decisionmaking that is an important element in the growing field of behavioral economics, which explores how human psychology. It is a concept which is not without controversy but the theory is widelyaccepted and you can test it for yourself. Tory higgins and nira liberman respond, as do itamar simonson and ran kivetz. This chapter analyzes monopoly and duopoly pricing when consumers display loss aversion. The utility function captures the loss aversion of individuals in a kink at the reference point, with the function being steeper in the losses region compared to the gains region.
The prospect theory starts with the concept of loss aversion, an asymmetric form of risk aversion, from the observation that people react differently between potential losses and potential gains. First, the model is applied to capture the idea that consumers are antagonized by unexpected price increases, and the implications of this idea for price rigidity and uniformity. See more ideas about economics books, economics and books. The curvature of diminishing marginal utility explains risk aversion and an asymmetric slope. Loss aversion the chocolate you lost can never be replaced. Pdf loss aversion, economic sentiments and international. Some of the best and most influential papers by amos tversky, one of the most brilliant social science thinkers of the twentieth century. In short, loss aversion describes the tendency in most people to favour avoiding losses over acquiring gains. The principle is very prominent in the domain of economics. For example, when making investment decisions we most often focus on the risks associated with the investment rather than the potential gains. David gal and derek ruckers the loss of loss aversion. We find that loss aversion and risk aversion cannot be disentangled empirically. Third, individuals exhibit diminishing sensitivity to gains and losses, i.
This behavior is at work when we make choices that include both the possibility of a loss or gain. According to valence loss aversion vla, valence losses are accentuated relative to corresponding valence gains. Pdf this paper estimates the risk preferences of cotton farmers in southern peru, using the. Camerer and george loewenstein i n the wealth of nations, published in 1776, adam smith famously argued that economic behavior was motivated by selfinterest. No, its not rational, but it does affect how you handle your money. How loss aversion in behavioral economics explains your.
Reference dependence is one of the fundamental principles of prospect theory and behavioral economics more generally. In behavioural economics, loss aversion refers to peoples preferences to avoid losing compared to gaining the equivalent amount. Current evidence does not support that losses, on balance, tend to be any more impactful than gains. The loss aversion principle states that the disutility of losing an object is two times greater than the utility of acquiring it.
A referencedependent model, the quarterly journal of economics, 106 4, november. It weaves together insights from cognitive and social psychology, neuropsychology, behavioral law and economics, experimental legal studies, economic analysis of law, normative ethics, moral psychology, and comparative law. Evidence from new york city public schools, journal of labor economics, university of chicago press, vol. Adam smith, behavioral economist nava ashraf, colin f. To capture the risk aversion intuition, the standard approach in economics has been to utilize the model of expected utility, in which risk aversion derives from modeling risk aversion in economics ted odonoghue is zubrow professor of economics and jason somerville is a phd student in economics, both at cornell university, ithaca, new york. This was demonstrated in a landmark study by daniel kahneman and amos trevsky in march 1979. The articles to be discussed will expansiate further on the concept of loss aversion that is why people seem to hate losing more than winning by discussing how convincing the two studies are, one article is on abstract reward and punishment representations in the human orbitofrontal cortex and the other article is on modeling loss. Loss aversion and duration of residence demographic research. See more ideas about loss aversion, psychology and behavioral economics. Prospect theory and economics future prospects free. Loss aversion the psychology of money series fqmom. This loss aversion indicates that the new disadvantage of y outweigh the forfeiture xs price advantage inferring on the reason why consumer hate losing than they enjoy wining. Definition of loss aversion, a central concept in prospect theory and behavioral economics. But 17 years earlier in 1759, smith had proposed a theory of human behavior that looks anything but selfinterested.
Loss aversion can prevent people from unloading unprofitable investments, even when they see little to no prospect of a turnaround. Apr 19, 2017 lets put it in economics parlance where utility is the unit of measurement of usefulness or satisfaction derived by the consumer when acquiring an object. Loss aversion in politics alberto alesinay francesco passarelliz first draft. Behavioral economics to appear in elseviers handbook of the. Reference dependence can apply to any decision involving risk and uncertainty. Lets hear about prospect theory and loss aversion from a nobel prize winner in economics professor robert shiller. Most people will behave so that they minimize losses because losses loom larger than gains, even though the probability of those losses is tiny. Loss aversion behavioural economics economics tutor2u. It is thought that the pain of losing is psychologically about twice as powerful as the pleasure of gaining. Amos tversky and daniel kahneman, 1991, loss aversion in riskless choice. This particular effect of behavioral economics explains why people are more likely to work to avoid a loss than they are to earn a gain. Optimal portfolio choice under loss aversion arjan b. March 2015 abstract we study loss aversion in majority voting. Prospect theory yale loss aversion applies in macro terms countries that undergo recessions see big wellbeing loss, even when growth brings limited benefits.
1096 179 801 1378 527 777 570 1268 160 1561 408 1472 61 132 1369 1477 447 995 438 1215 784 152 956 690 842 439 29 904 968 632 1310